You get the best of both worlds with this Sephora eyeliner. Yes, technically it isn’t designed for lips, but for those looking to reduce touch-ups throughout the day, this formula is both waterproof and long-lasting, built to last throughout whatever your day may bring.
Shades: 17
Sephora rating: 4.2/5 stars
An ELLE editor says: “A a few years ago, I had my makeup done by a makeup artist who suggested I switch my lip liner for an eyeliner or brow formula to help my lip color last longer. My first purchase was this Sephora eyeliner, which is retractable—perfect for someone like me, whose vanity is no place for a tiny sharpener. This pencil stays put through my morning lattes and even lunch. And throughout the day, it fades to a subtle, natural outline around my lips.”—Nerisha Penrose, beauty commerce editor